dailyO
Politics

Caste census reveals why India's farmers don't need Make in India or MNREGA

Advertisement
Manoj Joshi
Manoj JoshiJul 07, 2015 | 16:11

Caste census reveals why India's farmers don't need Make in India or MNREGA

India got a reality check on Saturday when newspapers splashed the shocking conclusions of the first Socio-Economic and Caste Census (SECC) since 1934 which revealed the extent of rural deprivation. Its primary finding was that rural households make up nearly three quarters of the country’s population, some 884 million people, and that an overwhelming 74 per cent of them survived on a monthly income of Rs 5,000 for its highest earner.

Advertisement

The message from these staggering numbers is obvious — India has to resolve some very basic issues within before it can aspire to be any kind of power, regional or global.

With agriculture contributing just 13.7 per cent to the Indian Gross Domestic Product, it is clear that the rural situation is a millstone around the country’s neck, rather than being an asset in the transformation of our economy. But this millstone happens to comprise of people — hundreds and millions of men women and children who are illiterate, poor and hungry.

Rural assets

More than half of these households do not own any land, the primary rural asset. And, neither are they able to create other assets because they lack education. 36 per cent of them are illiterate and the rest of those considered literate are barely so since they have not even completed high school. In practical terms a vast number of households have to struggle hard to get food, potable water, have no power or toilets. The consequences of this are illiteracy, malnutrition and vulnerability to disease. As another report being suppressed by the government and revealed by The Economist notes, that fully 30 per cent of the children of the country suffer from malnutrition and its terrible consequence of “stunting” and “wasting”— being abnormally short or underweight. You can be sure, most of these folk are from the rural areas too.

Advertisement

Over the years, a large number of people have worked their way out of poverty, gained literacy, acquired the trappings of middle class living like refrigerators, washing machines and a two or four wheeled vehicle. But the SECC has just opened our eyes to the sheer scale of poverty that continues to blight our land.

Because this deprivation is rural, many of those who make policy, read newspapers, shape the discourse of the country through the TV, never really get to grasp what it means. Hidden away in the backwaters of Bihar, Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh or Orissa, even minor illness of an earning member of the household can mean slow starvation and death. Sadly, richer states are not too different — 47.6 per cent of rural Rajasthan remains illiterate and the much touted Gujarat’s child malnutrition rates of 33.3 per cent are higher than the national average.

At a macro-level it is obvious that the country needs a manufacturing revolution, as Prime Minister Modi says, to shift these millions into productive occupations. But the issue is not simply one of investments, ease of doing business, FDI and the other buzz words you hear, but of a process that would first eliminate hunger and disease and provide education to the rural masses. The figures say, for example, that only 5.4 per cent of the people in rural India have completed high school, and only 3.4 per cent have graduated from college.

Advertisement

Red herrings

With these numbers, who or what will populate your factories? “Make in India” or MNREGA are red herrings. What the country needs to urgently work on is a sweeping agrarian revolution. For too long policy — essentially subsidising fertiliser and providing unsustainable support prices — has drifted. In the meantime, the size of holdings have declined, even as the number of persons dependent on those holdings has increased. The water table has dropped precipitously.

Biggest problem

But the biggest problem has been the fractured Indian agricultural market dominated as it is by Agriculture Produce Marketing Committees. The result is that there are situations where brinjal is selling for Rs 300 a quintal in Punjab and Rs 3,000 a quintal in Gujarat at the same time. Middlemen distort prices and availability of commodities. India does not have the option of forcing the process as was done in the Soviet Union and China and as the experience of countries like the US and Japan shows, it is not easy to reform the agricultural sector in democratic countries as well because of its political clout. But for India there is, perhaps, little choice. Politicians have been kicking the can down the road for the past decades. Now, they have accumulated to form the millstone that will block the progress of the country.

Bold steps to create a new agricultural paradigm else the country is condemned to be walking on the development treadmill for ever.

Last updated: July 08, 2015 | 15:44
IN THIS STORY
Please log in
I agree with DailyO's privacy policy