dailyO
Politics

Why the Dalai Lama is becoming the biggest bone of contention between India and China

Advertisement
Rajeev Sharma
Rajeev SharmaJun 26, 2018 | 12:12

Why the Dalai Lama is becoming the biggest bone of contention between India and China

Forget the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), Chinese president Xi Jinping's dream infrastructure project to link China not only with neighbourhood but also such faraway lands as Europe and Africa.

dalai690_062618120002.jpg

Forget the Pakistan-based India-centric terror fountainheads such as Masood Azhar and others, a topic that has long been a bone of contention between India and China.

Forget the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG), an international body where China has steadfastly opposed India's entry.

Advertisement

Also forget the stapled visa issue wherein China has been short-changing India for years by denying proper visas to Indians domiciled in Jammu and Kashmir and Arunachal Pradesh and giving them only stapled visas while China has been giving regular visas to residents of Pakistan Occupied Kashmir (PoK), a glaring example of China taking sides in the India-Pakistan dispute at the cost of India.

Yes, these have been the biggest red rags in India-China parleys, official as well as the backchannel ones. But none of these issues have engaged the two Asian giants as much as some other issues. Any guesses? Well, the answer is the fourteenth Dalai Lama, the supreme Tibetan spiritual leader whom China has riled for decades as a "separatist". Informatively, China has used many more disparaging words and expletives to describe the 82-year-old Dalai Lama who fled Tibet and crossed over to India 59 years ago.

The Dalai Lama has emerged as the biggest talking point in the India-China bilateral affairs through the back channels and informal parleys in 2018. The Dalai Lama was the central issue discussed between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping at their first-ever Wuhan Summit (April 27-28). In fact, it won't be an exaggeration to say that when President Xi travelled to Wuhan to meet PM Modi for his second informal summit ever with any foreign leader outside Beijing — and both times only for PM Modi — his main talking point this time was l'affaire Dalai Lama.

Advertisement

Never before the issue of the Dalai Lama had come centre stage like this between India and China. Never before the Dragon and the Elephant had discussed the Dalai Lama issue at highest levels with a laser beam focus as Xi and Modi did at Wuhan for eight hours in six separate outings together.

But that's what the Wuhan informal summit was by and large about, though, of course, all other contentious bilateral issues were discussed. The reason for such a deep focus of informal talks between Xi and Modi was because of the health concerns about the Dalai Lama.

No Indian prime minister ever discussed the Dalai Lama issue with top Chinese leadership so intensely as PM Modi has done. This is not without a pragmatic rationale.

When on February 22, 2018, foreign secretary Vijay Gokhale sent a note to cabinet secretary PK Sinha asking "senior leaders" and "government functionaries" of the Centre and states to stay away from events planned for March-end and early April by the "Tibetan leadership in India" to mark the start of 60 years in exile of the Dalai Lama, the real reason for this unprecedented move was a mystery.

Advertisement

But the real cause was intelligence information that the Dalai Lama is suffering from terminal-stage prostate cancer. First only New Delhi got to know of this but later on Beijing too got wind of it. That's how the two sides came to discuss the Dalai Lama-centric issues at Wuhan.

The Modi government, which became aware of this development over a year ago, turned attention to this only in the beginning of this year as it started checking its diplomatic toolbox vis-à-vis China. A policy decision was taken at the highest levels by the Modi government in February as the fear of Doklam II started haunting it. At that time the Modi government was nearing completion of four years or 80 per cent of its tenure.

lama690_062618115847.jpg

More importantly, disturbing news had started pouring from Doklam, the site of a 73-day-long standoff between Indian and Chinese militaries. On March 5, 2018, defence minister Nirmala Sitharaman informed the Lok Sabha that the People's Liberation Army (PLA) of China has undertaken "construction of some infrastructure, including sentry posts, trenches and helipads" near the face-off site between Indian and Chinese troops at Doklam in the Sikkim-Bhutan-Tibet tri-junction area.

Sitharaman's reply to a question in the Lok Sabha had come after media reports that the PLA had constructed military infrastructure and helipads and deployed around 1,600 troops in north Doklam throughout the winter for the first time.

From Modi government's perspective, time was running out to send a conciliatory message to China and prevent a Doklam II which would have been politically disastrous for it, months ahead of the general elections. It was time for some out of the box thinking. It was time for the Modi government to extend a CBM (Confidence Building Measure) which would appeal the most to China.

This was the time when the Modi government turned its attention to intelligence reports about the Dalai Lama's health. All these inputs were enough to lead the Modi government on to an unusual diplomatic expedition vis-à-vis China and try to please the Chinese by disassociating government functionaries from the Dalai Lama's programmes, at least for some time.

However, there is a downside for the Modi government in this episode. As the Chinese government is fully updated about the Dalai Lama's health, it obviously means that they can see through the tactics of the Modi government!

It's here that the wheels-within-wheels kind of diplomacy kicks in. Apparently, China wants the Dalai Lama to travel to Tibet. But will India allow it, knowing full well that it may be a one-way ticket for the Dalai Lama?

Can India take such a decision vis-à-vis the supreme Tibetan spiritual leader who has been India's guest for last 59 years and is a major pivotal figure and a rallying point against China for the US-led Western world?

There are no answers to these questions as of now. But the drift I get is that India won't be obliging China in this regard. Not now, not ever.

Last updated: June 27, 2018 | 10:56
IN THIS STORY
Please log in
I agree with DailyO's privacy policy