Why Donald Trump delivered a masterful address at Motera

Kanwal Sibal
Kanwal SibalFeb 25, 2020 | 11:06

Why Donald Trump delivered a masterful address at Motera

The US President’s speech struck all the right notes about Modi’s leadership and India’s achievements under him.

US President Donald Trump’s visit has got off to a better start than one could have expected. His Sabarmati Ashram visit along with his wife with hands at Mahatma Gandhi’s spinning wheel sent a subtle message, given Gandhiji’s simplicity and Trump’s ostentation, Gandhiji’s abhorrence of violence contrasted with a President who boasts of having spent $2.5 trillion on rebuilding the US military.

The visit was image-burnishing for the moment as it made him look less vain.

Struck the right note

Trump’s speech at the Motera stadium surpassed expectations in many ways. Speeches on such occasions are audience-oriented, but constructing the right message and giving it substance beyond the usual pleasant rhetoric requires savviness.


His speech struck all the right notes about Modi’s leadership and India’s achievements under him. He was lavish in referring to him as “an exceptional leader”, a “champion of India”, a “great Prime Minister”, and a “tremendously successful leader”.

He noted his electoral victory at the largest election anywhere (at least in this respect Trump conceded Modi is ahead of him).

Even allowing for Trump’s penchant for inflated vocabulary, this kind of unstinted praise on Indian soil before a massive audience, relayed nationwide on TV and other media sends a powerful message to those in India, the US and elsewhere in the West who have bought the narrative of Modi as dividerin-chief, anti-Muslim and a Hindu chauvinist presiding over an intolerant India.

On the eve of Trump’s visit, a US spokesperson let it be known that Trump will in public and private raise the issue of religious freedom and India will be encouraged to uphold its demo cratic traditions and institutions.

None of this was hinted at in Trump’s speech, but the visit is not over. One hopes that at Delhi during the joint press meeting or a separate press briefing by Trump to the US press, or in some factsheet issued by the US embassy, this kind of American concern is not mentioned or listed.

Otherwise it would give the Opposition the stick they want to beat the Modi government with and will cast an unwanted shadow on the remarkably positive results of the visit so far.

Trump was visibly overwhelmed by the rousing welcome he got. He will not get a welcome on such a scale anywhere else. Trump is popular in India, but beyond that, aspirational India responds positively to America.

The repeated hugs between the two leaders, with no reticence on Trump’s side, shows that the level of comfort at the personal level between them is now strong, though how far this will get translated into hard ball negotiations on many issues is a matter of speculation. It is interesting that Trump twice mentioned how “tough” Modi is. If Modi can be tough, so can Trump.

All praise for the PM

Trump acknowledged in glowing terms India’s astounding progress, calling it a miracle of democracy, referring to Indians as “strong and noble people”, a “hope for all humanity”.

He validated Modi’s achievements in providing electricity to all villages, the 320 million Internet connections, cooking gas connections, huge success in sanitation, poverty eradication, highway construction, etc.

In a veiled reference to China, he noted this has been achieved democratically and peacefully as a free country, with respect for dignity of every person, trust in its cit izenry, and without coercion, intimidation or aggression.

His well-crafted speech made appealing references to India’s culture and civilisation, citing Vivekanand, Bollywood’s creativity, Indian cricket icons, Sardar Patel’s monumental statue, the meaning of Diwali, Holi, the many religions living peacefully side by side, rule of law, and so on.

He paid a handsome tribute to the four million people of Indian origin in America.

Cautious on Pakistan

He used the occasion to dwell on the growing defence cooperation with India, noting the first ever trilateral exercise, praising the high quality of American defence equipment, indicating interest in selling drones and air defence equipment to India, announcing that $3 billion worth of defence deals that will be signed in Delhi, and declaring that the US intends to be India’s premier defence partner, a statement that the Russians will no doubt note.

Trump mentioned his iron-clad resolve to counter radical Islamic terrorism, noting that both countries were hurt by terrorism and, importantly, that every nation had a right to secure and control its borders to counter terrorists and their ideology.

He asked Pakistan to crack down on terrorism on its soil, but said that the US has a good relationship with it and sees signs of progress on terrorism there.

In this context, he alluded implicitly to India’s role in promoting peace and harmony in South Asia and helping shape a better future for the region.

This was the only false note in his address, made no doubt with the impending peace deal with the Taliban with Pakistan’s support in view.

On the trade front he made some general comments, noting that the discussions were in early stages and that he was optimistic about reaching a “fantastic deal”, which might mean increased pressure on India. All in all, a masterful performance at Motera. Now let’s see what lies ahead.

(Courtesy of Mail Today)

Last updated: February 25, 2020 | 11:07
Please log in
I agree with DailyO's privacy policy